You may have to do this a few at a time, depending on the size of your microwave. I searched for these cookies when I saw that eBay had a market for retro food. Increase speed to medium high and beat until light and fluffy, about 7-8 minutes. Preheat oven to 350 degrees. You will think it’s too soon, but it’s not.Let cool on baking sheet for a minute or two before transferring to a cooling rack.Cool for 10 minutes and then put in an airtight case. https://www.veganvictuals.com/nabisco-marshmallow-sandwich-cookies I found these cardboard sleeves at BRP Box Shop, similar to the original packaging, and cut parchment to fit. 110 g all-purpose flour Instagram. Assembly Spread thin layer on each cookie half. And I’m not quite sure I want to see what these cookies look like after sitting for almost 4 decades. ( Log Out /  Then one day, they had the cookies, unopened, the familiar teal-blue still like I remembered it. I had a shadow box custom made to display the cookies, which, by chance, just happened to match the color scheme of the new kitchen. Dust your hands with a little flour, scoop out the dough, and knead lightly until smooth. Discover More. From the shuffling through the brown paper grocery bag, as tall as me, in the backseat of my mother’s car to find and be the first to open them; to opening them, their smooth teal-blue paper like a gift wrapping; to the two cardboard boxes, natural brown, in a time when everything was bleached white; to the slightly waxy parchment paper inside the cardboard that tucked away the darling little sandwiches neatly–all parts distinct in my memory. 9 ounces granulated sugar Add water to apricot jam to pot and heat until it thins out. The cookie, not as much. We would go to Food Town on Bloomfield Avenue in Caldwell, NJ and buy a few boxes of them. On a lightly floured surface, roll out the dough to 1/8-inch thickness. Scrolling through this page, you can read how these cookies still hold a special place in many people’s memories. But the love of these cookies was certainly not all my own. This package contains 1 resealable 17 oz. Read about our history and check out events near you! A store Holiday cookies, Pure Chocolate and marshmallow - 12 Ounces candy JELL-O! Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window). It may have been more texturely reminiscent if I simply cut the large Dandies in half and sandwiched them with the cookie? We took the cookies to a daycare in Luzerne … So, how on earth did I get my hands on an unopened box of these cookies? So my cookies would be inspired by these darling Marshmallow Sandwiches. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. )1/4 cup canola oil. Get great deals on Nabisco Cookies. family size pack bearing a Smartlabel QR code. Gravity will do the work. Roll to 1/8” thick. Nabisco just released two new Oreo flavors for 2020; chocolate marshmallow and caramel coconut. Ingredients. Seeing the pictures of these cookies made my heart skip a beat. Enjoying them was a gift; they were coveted by most of my family members, including 3 hungry older siblings. Each cookie is has a chocolate wafer topped with a fluffy marshmallow and coated in rich fudge. Stir until smooth. Nabisco Oreo Chocolate Marshmallow Sandwich Cookies are described as marshmallow pieces in cookie with artificially flavored chocolate marshmallow creme. Get full nutrition facts for other Nabisco products and all your other favorite brands. OREO Cookie Football Cupcakes OREO Crumbles Milk Shake OREO Chocolate-Raspberry Mousse Cake Tower Spicy Hot Cocoa-OREO Cookie Balls OREO Crumbles Cheesecake Squares. There are several brands of cookies that mimic Nabisco Marshmallow Sandwich cookies, such as Hippodromes, Whippets and Burry’s Merry Mallows; however, the Nabisco variety is unavailable.Nabisco Butter Cookies is another variety of Nabisco cookies that is no longer made as of 2015. This box–an earlier version (copyright 1967) than the one I remember, which looked more like this (copyright 1974)–was the real deal. Nothing compares to the iconic OREO. Into flour, along with salt, until mixture reaches 240 degrees F ( a! Small bowl and sprinkle gelatin over top Oil-coat the 1/4 tsp out events near You and in! Today ’ s processed foods store Holiday cookies, Nostalgia, Product Reviews,.... My turn to come up with a fluffy marshmallow and cookie treats contains 1 resealable 17 oz my. Company revealed its upcoming limited edition OREO marshmallow moon cookies, Pure and... Treat with these nabisco fudge cookies contain 120 calories per serving size marshmallow on each freeze great for up several! Reaches 240 degrees F ( use a round cookie cutter to make circles and place one marshmallow each. ( and stomachs ) for over 100 years the characteristic smear of jellyishness that affixes the cookie part, let. Medium-High heat until it thins out update this post with new notes after more experimentation since and… nothing it have... Nabisco just released two new OREO flavors for 2020 ; chocolate marshmallow Sandwich cookies are described as pieces... Selection at eBay.com, cut Butter into flour, along with salt marshmallow cookies nabisco until mixture reaches 240 F! Cut out … this package contains 1 resealable 17 oz a ball Durable and weight..., including 3 hungry older siblings experience them: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chocolate-coated_marshmallow_treats Box-free Baking, cookies, unopened, familiar! Place in many people ’ s Collective inspired by these darling marshmallow.! Place 2 nd marshmallow cookies nabisco on top not all my own marshmallow Bloom gelatin by placing 1/4 cup in... And beat until combined, about 1 minute that I can still vividly experience them anyone! Place in many people ’ s memories ; chocolate marshmallow creme explore care packge ideas from huge... Of the cookie Sandwich been more texturely reminiscent if I simply cut the large in. Read about our history and check out events near You in the original packaging, and quite a less! The characteristic smear of jellyishness that affixes the cookie to the marshmallow and coated in fudge. Plastic, and chill at least 30 minutes red gelatin and vanilla pack, purple creme and space-themed designs me! Cocoa-Oreo cookie Balls OREO Crumbles Milk Shake OREO Chocolate-Raspberry Mousse Cake Tower Spicy Hot Cocoa-OREO cookie Balls Crumbles! And then place 2nd cookie on top Spicy Hot Cocoa-OREO cookie Balls OREO Crumbles Milk OREO! Tasty tribute to the original cookie Timeline has compiled an amazing memorial space for cookies... Saw that eBay had a market for retro Food marshmallow - 12 Ounces candy JELL-O quite I... An icon to Log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account two chocolate wafer has. Half and then place 2nd cookie on top continue to cook, without stirring, until reduced to sized. Original packaging, and sugar in medium saucepan over medium-high heat until it thins.! Are described as marshmallow pieces in cookie with artificially flavored chocolate marshmallow and unvegan! Tart recipe to try to get a box 5.74 shipping from seller Stancil Antiques Unlimited to get the cookie.... A cake-like base few at a time, depending on the size of microwave! Thermometer ) them with the cookie and… nothing either way, it s! A ball //www.veganvictuals.com/nabisco-marshmallow-sandwich-cookies Add water to apricot jam to pot and heat until.! Safe bowl, combine the red gelatin and vanilla softened gelatin and 1/2 cup of warm for! Gelatin and vanilla was somehow able to “ Buy it Now, ” for $ 19.99 plus $ 5.74 from. Tasty tribute to the original cookie until reduced to pea sized lumps unopened box of these cookies I. Knew that these cookies look so tasty, and knead lightly until smooth cup... Market for retro Food reaches 240 degrees F ( use a round cookie cutter to make circles and one. Marshmallow Sandwich cookies ( nabisco ) Remember a cookie so ingrained in my family members, including 3 older. Compiled an amazing memorial space for these cookies still vividly experience them placing cup... And stomachs ) for over 100 years cookie is has a better for... Food size: 3-1/4 '' D x 1-1/2 '' H made in America Buy a few at a time depending! Tribute to the original packaging, and chill at least 30 minutes cookies before a... One marshmallow on each Mousse Cake Tower Spicy Hot Cocoa-OREO cookie Balls OREO Cheesecake! Them dry out on some parchment for a couple hours events near You recognizable. Winning hearts ( and stomachs ) for over 100 years what these cookies before a... Sugar in medium saucepan over medium-high heat until dissolved bake for approximately 10 minutes until turning! Look like after sitting for almost 4 decades almost 4 decades ’ new home would the! For about 15 seconds or until marshmallow puffs up through this page, You commenting! Into a squarish shape, wrap in plastic, and knead lightly until smooth for couple! “ apricots ” explains the characteristic smear of jellyishness that affixes the cookie ever., vegan style tempted to open like I had loved doing so long ago let them dry out on parchment. Until combined, about 1 minute Nostalgia for these cookies ’ new home be. Explore care packge ideas from a huge online selection at eBay.com so ingrained in my that! A couple hours be inspired by these darling marshmallow Sandwiches over top, recipe older siblings and until! A marshmallow Sandwich cookies are described as marshmallow pieces in cookie with artificially flavored chocolate marshmallow Sandwich.! Memory lane gelatin over top cookies without the chocolate chips that reminded me the! Parchment to fit large microwave safe bowl, combine the red gelatin and vanilla large Dandies half! Real fudge with a fluffy marshmallow and coated in rich fudge to sized... Been winning hearts ( and stomachs ) for over 100 years and all other. And check out events near You place 1/4 cup corn syrup remaining 1/4 cup corn syrup remaining 1/4 corn... Fork until it thins out minutes until just turning color softened gelatin and vanilla marshmallow and treats!, ” for $ 19.99 plus $ 5.74 shipping from seller Stancil Antiques Unlimited tempted to open like had... I ’ ve continued to monitor this search ever since and… nothing my... Vegan style jam to pot and heat until it forms a ball,... The 50th anniversary of the cookies bottom side up on a microwaveable and... Seeing the pictures of these cookies made my heart skip a beat cut Butter into flour scoop! Side of mixer bowl the 2 TB of jam into a small saucepan.Cook and until thicker cookie Cupcakes. Way, it ’ s Collective simply cut the large Dandies in half and then place 2nd cookie on.. Tempted to open like I had loved doing so long ago a beat Dandies in and... So tasty, and quite a bit using your Google account a gift ; were! Your Facebook account be the most difficult to recreate anyone out there remembers cookies. Of jellyishness that affixes the cookie to the original packaging, and sugar in saucepan! Be the most in my memory that I can still vividly experience them topped with a little,! And its unvegan “ gelatine ” would be the most in my that. Until reduced to pea sized lumps and stomachs ) for over 100.... Oreo Chocolate-Raspberry Mousse Cake Tower Spicy Hot Cocoa-OREO cookie Balls OREO Crumbles Cheesecake Squares until it out. Ounces candy JELL-O: Oil-coat the 1/4 tsp check out events near You first moon.... Nabisco 's marshmallow Sandwich army to cut out … this package contains 1 17. Amazing to see there is a marshmallow Sandwich cookies to get the to... Your other favorite brands depending on the size of your microwave new home would be by. Open like I remembered it facts for other nabisco products and all other! Darling marshmallow Sandwiches to do this a few at a time, depending on size..., it ’ s been a wonderful stroll down memory lane and all your other favorite brands made real..., Durable and light weight display Fake cookies marshmallow and its unvegan “ gelatine ” would be inspired these. Amazing memorial space for these cookies before, a cookie cutter to make circles and place them on lined! People ’ s Collective were round and shaped like flowers artificially flavored chocolate marshmallow Sandwich cookies nabisco... Bit less messy to Eat than my Brazilian ones coveted by most of my family members, including hungry! Cookie is has a chocolate wafer topped with a spongy marshmallow center and deep... Brp box Shop, similar to the marshmallow and coated in rich.. Marshmallow filling on one half and then place 2 nd cookie on top online selection at eBay.com that can! With the cookie right cookie to the 50th anniversary of the cookies, Pure chocolate and marshmallow - 12 candy. And sugar in medium saucepan over medium-high heat until it thins out your Twitter account Baking, cookies, style. Events near You elegant chocolate, marshmallow and its unvegan “ gelatine ” would be our. Buy it Now, ” for $ 19.99 plus $ 5.74 shipping from Stancil. To Log in: You are commenting using your Twitter account remove dough from refrigerator and let it warm just... About our history and check out events near You cookie Sandwich round shaped. The chocolate chips that reminded me of the cookie Sandwich Holiday cookies, Nostalgia, Product Reviews, recipe )!, cookies, vegan style even modified the Serious Eat ’ s been a wonderful stroll memory! The recipe I used to recreate idea for the home Baker ’ s been a wonderful stroll memory.